DSLRUsers.com

I like the color version of this image but I have a B&W competition coming up
Is this worth entering?
any ideas on different Processing? is it too dark?

Asylum


this is a color version there is still more space above and to each side for alternate crops


all comments appreciated

I'm undecided as to whether I like the mono or the colour the best... at first glance i thought the mono... but I am thinking that if you cropped the ceiling out of the colour it would come close to beating it...

I really do like this image btw.. its very eyecatching..

Great work.

It's a tough choice. But I'd have to go with the b&w version.
And the crop is much better too..

Also, I think it needs a slight tilt to the right?

Cheers.

I prefer the B&W but would like to see it lightened slightly to bring the guy sitting on the right back into the picture a little more.

Love the shot though.

Keith,

Great image.

I prefer the B&W too, and I'm wondering about yet a different crop: remove some of the floor ... dunno, but might be worth playing with.

I agree with the comment about trying to bring in a little more depth for the person on the extreme right.

And I can't help but think of yet a different crop ... just the person on the left ... with the caption "does my bum look big in this?"

I like the BW too...

A wacky thought from me, crop the left hand side to half the room, and mirror flip it into the other side...

Depends what you are going for

The color: The feature that draws my eye is that wall the tones are just great

The mono: The people draw my eye.

I think I prefer the tones and feel of the color. You should crop it to remove about 10% on each side.

They both work. Have faith!