I prefer the first one, but in both cases, you've amputated bits of the anumal.
It's a common error for younger players - failing to examine the whole viewfinder to ensure that they have the complete image that they want, and it often leads to things like amputated feet, or trees growing out of the heads of a bride, or a stranger walking through the otherwise barren and uninhabited background ....
All it takes in an extra half second with the camera uo to your eye to scan the image area, and perhaps adjust the camera down a little, or pull the zoom back a few mm.